Parent Trap 3 – Explaining to a Child why a Behaviour is Wrong will Lead to Better Behaviour

Truth is, you can explain why a behaviour is wrong all you like but I can assure you that that in itself will not get your child to stop that behaviour.

Look at it this way, how many adults know that regular exercise is good for you or that smoking is terribly dangerous to you health.   And despite this in depth knowledge how many still struggle to squeeze in 30 mins of exercise a week leave alone daily and how many continue to enjoy a few cigarettes a day?

Well, children are no different.  Knowing that certain behaviour is not correct, doesn’t equate to a cessation of that behaviour.

Don’t get me wrong.  When it comes to children, explanation definitely has a place in parenting, such as for teaching your child the difference between right and wrong, in IQ building, improving understanding and more.  But as a way of change behaviour, never has there been a more ineffective tool.   

So yes, explaining why a certain behaviour is right, but if you want to stop that particular behaviour you would need to do more.  Understanding and doing are two different things, even for us adults, so you can imagine for children…

So what to do instead?

By all means, do use explanations but couple this with another strategy such as:

  noticing, encouraging and praising your child’s good behaviour especially with regards to the particular behaviour you are trying to deal with.  Observe your child as much as possible and each time you see them behave in an acceptable way, e.g. had a playdate and didn’t hurt anyone,  praise them for that. Remember make that praise, clear, descriptive and precise.

  • don’t just explain, show him how to behave correctly.  Demonstrate what is expected and then provide her with opportunities to practice the behaviour and when she does it well, let her know and…praise her.
  • create a behavioural chart (if unsure how, let me know). Please note that for charts to work well and effectively, you will need to create them in a way that won’t set you up to fail and your child neither
  • remember to always have a back-up logical consequence for when the unwanted behaviour rears it’s head and act quickly.  If you need to revert to your chosen consequence, do let your child know, exactly what he has done wrong and what the consequence will be e.g. “That’s it Lilly. You have hurt your friend, so now you’ll have to sit on the side away from the activity for 2 mins.”

What I have offered you here are some Triple P – Positive Parenting Program techniques which are truly very effective but you need, as always to remain consistent for them to work. 

There’s a fab book that talks in more detail about the 7 parent traps.  It’s by Dr Kazdin and it’s entitled “The Kazdin Method for Parenting the Defiant Child.

So as you can see, explanations are good in part but are ineffective used solo.  

Any questions?  Email me or contact me.

You’ll find:

Parent Trap 1 here

Parent Trap 2 here 

Leave a Reply